ARM Technical Support Knowledge Articles

PL340: *Denali* Error: Bank 0 must be in the active state before accepting command 'Read'.


I have a scenario where read access to a classical DDR memory is made via chip select 1.

Read access to NVM-DDR on chip select 0 and write accesses to DDR on chip select 1 work fine but the first read access to the DDR via chip select 1 fails. The related denali error message is:

# *Denali* Error: </alv_tb_chip/a_extmem_subsys/memory_cs1_e1/a_ddr_4/memory>@1489165810 ps :: Bank 0 must be in the active state before accepting command 'Read'. Bank 0 is in the Idle state.
For the read command to DDR on chip select 1, I realized that there is no 'activate' command preceeding the read command. I would expect an initial 'normal' read operation sequence to be be preceeded by an 'activate' command.


This could possibly be a clock syncronization issue.  First, check that an activate command is in fact being attempted by the PL340.  You should check the following input signals to module pl340_padif_PL340r3_xxx_xxxx.v:

Command_cs_n = CSx
Command_ras_n = 0
Command_cas_n = 1
Command_we_n = 1

If the above signals are set correctly, then check the outputs of this same module:

Cs_n = ?
Ras_n = ?
Cas_n = ?
We_n = ?

The following code block controls whether the inputs to this module reach the outputs correctly. 

Always @ (posedge mclkn or negedge mresetn_n)
    ras_n <= command_ras_n
    cas_n <= command_cas_n
    we_n <= command_we_n
    cs_n <= command_cs_n

If they are not correctly reaching the outputs, then check whether you have set the clock synchronization bits correctly in the memory_cfg2 register:

Bit 1: a_gt_m_sync - Requires to be set HIGH when running the aclk and mclk synchronously but with aclk running faster than mclk.
Bit 0: Set high when aclk and mclk are synchronous.Looking at the waveforms, it looks like you've only set bit 0.

Rate this article

Disagree? Move your mouse over the bar and click

Did you find this article helpful? Yes No

How can we improve this article?

Link to this article
Copyright © 2011 ARM Limited. All rights reserved. External (Open), Non-Confidential